Toomas Hendrik Ilves: Grow up, “anonymous EU officials” – Kaja Kallas is the EU’s foreign minister

Representatives of the EU’s larger member states are unnerved by the competence Kaja Kallas brings to her role as the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, writes Toomas Hendrik Ilves, a former president of Estonia.

This article originally appeared on Toomas Hendrik Ilves’s Substack and has been lightly edited.

Old enough to remember the debates around the constitution/Lisbon Treaty on the need for European “foreign minister”?

The position ended up called the High Representative for Common Foreign and Security Policy, ie the EU’s foreign minister. Since the treaty came into force in 2009, that has been the stated function of the High Rep.

If you remember that, you will also remember all the self-congratulatory back-slapping over how “Europe finally has an answer to Henry Kissinger’s ‘If I want to call Europe, who(m) do I call?’”

European presidents and prime ministers, the “heads of state and government”, haven’t really wanted anyone usurping the possibility of getting that phone call from whomever is the day’s Henry Kissinger. Nor have they been willing to give up the prospect of grandstanding and playing statesmen on the world stage. Nicolas Sarkozy, Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron all have relished the headlines and attention they garnered outside their own countries. Smaller member state leaders have tried as well.

Incompetent predecessors

So after establishing the post of foreign minister, heads of state and government proceeded to appoint High Representatives for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy who had never held the highest office in a member state. Better to pick someone from a lesser background. This way there would be no competition.

Thus, we first got Labourite foreign policy novice Cathy Ashton, whose previous claim to prominence was as treasurer of the UK’s Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. Next came Federica Mogherini, the hardly more competent but certainly more arrogant and partisan young socialist who had briefly served as Italy’s foreign minister. In her subsequent sinecure heading the College of Europe, she ended up accused of corruption. She in turn was followed by the hapless socialist Josep Borrell, primarily remembered for commiserating with Sergei Lavrov over US policies towards Cuba.

Neither Mogherini nor Borrell, however, ever took any kind of role in the EU’s response to Russia’s aggression in Ukraine. They observed. They expressed 50 shades of “concern”. Nor, to be fair, did they know much about foreign policy. In particular, they lacked any serious understanding of Russia.

Josep Borrell answers questions from the European Parliament’s Committee on Foreign Affairs at his confirmation hearing in 2019. Kaja Kallas succeeded him as the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy in 2024. Photo: European Parliament / CC BY 2.0 licence.
Josep Borrell answers questions from the European Parliament’s Committee on Foreign Affairs at his confirmation hearing in 2019. Kaja Kallas succeeded him as the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy in 2024. Photo: European Parliament / CC BY 2.0 licence.

Kaja Kallas, in contrast to her predecessors, had been a prime minister. By the time she was appointed, most of the current heads of state and government on the European Council had been her colleagues. Also in contrast to her predecessors, she had a deep knowledge of both foreign policy and the history of Russian behaviour towards its European neighbours.

Kaja Kallas is Rubio’s and Lavrov’s EU counterpart

It is especially galling to hear EU leaders complain (always anonymously) that Kallas “only cares about Russia”. For one thing, that is untrue. For another, what country besides Russia shares a border with five EU member states? What other country is waging a horrific genocidal war on a European country, Ukraine, which happens to border four EU member states? Any “top diplomat” of the EU who does not make that war his or her biggest priority should be fired.

Yet now we see EU leaders jockeying for position to be the one to talk to Lavrov and to Putin. Fine. Never mind that it makes the European Union look silly and unserious. Never mind that it ignores the EU’s own constitutional order.

Kaja Kallas, High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy and Vice President of the European Commission, addresses the UN Security Council meeting on threats to international peace and security on 22 September 2025. Photo by UN.
Kaja Kallas, High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy and Vice President of the European Commission, addresses the UN Security Council meeting on threats to international peace and security on 22 September 2025. Photo by UN.

The point, however, is that, as the Lisbon Treaty sets out, the High Representative represents the EU in matters of foreign and security policy. Kaja Kallas is, by our own rules, the counterpart and proper interlocutor of both Rubio and Lavrov. António Costa is the counterpart and interlocutor of both Putin and Trump.

If the EU’s leaders suppress their egos and respect the treaty their countries have ratified, the High Representative should be the one to run the EU’s foreign policy.

The opinions in this article are those of the author.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top